Sherlock Review: His Last Vow


As with my reviews for “Hearse” and “Sign,” this one will contain a spoiler-free section followed by a marked spoiler section.

Part I: Spoiler Free

Well, twelve days later, we’re one season further in the progression of Sherlock, finished with a third series that gave us a finale that was at the same time one of the most and least traditional episodes the series has produced. Penned by writer and showrunner Steven Moffat, “His Last Vow” was, in many ways, a close re-telling of “The Adventure of Charles Augustus Milverton” — to a point.

Canon devotees will find a huge amount to love about the episode, which gave nods to Doyle both great and small, through plot events and characters. Those who have joined the fandom for the show alone will also find ample examples of what makes Sherlock great as a series.

It’s difficult to talk about this episode without spoilers, but suffice to say that Lars Mikkelsen imbues Charles Augustus Magnussen with every hateful fiber of Doyle’s master blackmailer, and in some ways, in my opinion, the connections Moffat wove between the story and characters we already love improved a great story by adding depth and suspense.

In terms of direction, “His Last Vow” wasn’t my favorite, but the superb acting and writing were enough to overcome a few confusing moments. Amanda Abbington proved once again that she can go toe-to-toe with two of the best actors in the business, and touching performances by Mark Gatiss, Louise Brealey, and the delightful Timothy Carlton and Wanda Ventham (Benedict Cumberbatch’s real-life parents) rounded out the emotionally harrowing story.

“His Last Vow” completes this season’s superb trilogy in a fitting way, bringing to a conclusion the questions it raised, and bringing us, the audience, closer to the characters we’ve come to love, all while letting us tag along with a nail-biting mystery. May Series 4 not be long behind.

Part II: Spoilers

It was frenetic; it was suspenseful; it was heartbreaking. “His Last Vow” finally gave us the truth about Mary Morstan and showed how far Sherlock Holmes is willing to go to protect his friends.

The opening nod to “The Man with the Twisted Lip” and the introduction of (Billy) Wiggins were wonderful treats for canon lovers, and the first half hour trajectory of the episode appeared to be sticking almost completely to the Doyle story–until Magnussen’s would-be shooter pulled off her face mask.

I wasn’t surprised to learn that Mary Morstan had a past, and I thought it was fitting that we never found out exactly what it was. Through her story, we learned even more completely what a truly good-hearted person John Watson is. We also learned that Sherlock Holmes has a personal vision of justice–one in which he appraises people’s characters in his own way, forgiving the woman who put a bullet through him and putting his own bullet through someone else.

I imagine there will be debate about Sherlock’s final solution to the Magnussen problem. First of all, it’s canonical. Though he doesn’t fire the bullet himself, Holmes stands by and willingly lets Milverton be killed in front of him when he could easily prevent it. Secondly, the question of the killing itself. Both in the canon and in Sherlock, Milverton is the most despicable of criminals, even more so than Moriarty. He may not have personally pulled the trigger, but he is unequivocally responsible for the deaths of hundreds, probably thousands, of people whose lives he’s ruined. He’s as close to pure evil as Doyle comes in the canon. He’s also beyond normal justice. He’s so powerful and so connected that what Holmes allows (in the story) and carries out (in “His Last Vow”) is an act that is in service to queen and country, family, and friends. He saves Mary, but he also saves the world from extraordinary evil. Does a moral question remain? Perhaps, but Doyle found Milverton worthy of death, and Sherlock chose the same course for Magnussen for the same reasons.

As I stated above, the directing of “Vow” bothered me a little bit. I missed (previous director) Paul McGuigan’s extraordinarily deft touch and found myself lost for a few seconds more than once, trying to understand the passage of time and order of events. This didn’t keep me from enjoying the episode, but I couldn’t help but think another director’s pacing and style might have done it slightly better justice.

Ultimately, thinking back to Series 1, Episode 1, “A Study in Pink,” it’s as if we’ve made an extraordinarily long and rewarding circle. “Vow” ended with Sherlock Holmes doing for John Watson what Watson did for him at the end of the beginning–eliminating his greatest threat. It left us with a Holmes who is needed in London once again to confront a familiar threat, with his best friend by his side and a brother whose love for him is made no less potent by the complications of its expression. Once again, I keep thinking of Inspector Lestrade and his elegantly simple assessment of Sherlock Holmes as a great man who might some day be good. Series 3 of Sherlock has completed the transformation, and I look forward to what’s to come.

(With special thanks to my friend @tastytrix on Twitter, who started me thinking about the circularity of Sherlock’s and John’s actions. Follow her; she’s fabulous.)


The Detective, The Woman and The Winking Tree: A Novel of Sherlock Holmes is available from all good bookstores and e-bookstores worldwide including in the USA Amazon,Barnes and Noble and Classic Specialities – and in all electronic formats including Amazon Kindle , iTunes(iPad/iPhone) and Kobo.

The Detective and the Woman: A Novel of Sherlock Holmes is available from all good bookstores and e-bookstores worldwide including in the USA Amazon,Barnes and Noble and Classic Specialities – and in all electronic formats including Amazon Kindle , iTunes(iPad/iPhone) and Kobo.

7 thoughts on “Sherlock Review: His Last Vow

  1. Nice review though this episode for me was a very mixed bag. The Mary storyline was great and the “tells” in e1 & 2 were nice and subtle. And the close was a big “yes!” moment though surprised by how many actually thought Moriarty was really dead given the clues to the contrary in series 2.

    I would have loved to have seen more malevolence from CAM and real threats to HM and the world as a whole. A character that came too late and left too soon to have any genuine impact. (Brilliantly played btw)

    Sherlock thinking that CAM used some sort of sophisticated Google Glass, really? And Holmes asking Watson about the gun, purely telegraphed the conclusion. Even the wife who gets nothing shouted, “Sherlock is going to shoot him!”.

    And still too many questions left from series 2 unanswered.

    Don’t get me wrong, enjoyable but for sure not nearly the best of the 9 episodes. Has been a great series; first 2 episodes wonderful, this one good but not really in keeping with all that has gone before. And because of that it has almost felt like a filler series until s4 comes along, more so with the confirmation that Moriarty is finally coming back.

    • Interesting thoughts. I definitely didn’t share the impression that CAM was a weak threat. I thought he was terrifying, to me and within the Sherlock world. I would have liked to see the episode directed slightly differently, but I thought it was a good one. As for knowing Holmes was going to shoot him, it was a fairly canonical eventuality, so I wasn’t looking to be too surprised there.

      • Oh don’t get me wrong, I felt he was a very calculating and menacing threat at start and played superbly. But to see him brought to his hands and knees by Mary with a gun and Mycroft stating that he never really done that much damage, I just didn’t get the same chills I did when Moriarty made his grand entrance for those brief few minutes at end of series 1. Direction could have a part to play in that. Would have loved to seem much more of CAM and get a feel for what menace he was truly capable of.

        But again, I enjoyed, just expected a little more I guess 🙂

  2. Each season has ended with a “strongest episode” and that is the case here. The twists and surprises of the first 30 minutes are brilliant. As with the “Fall” episode last season, I am hugely impressed with the subtlety of the modern kind of threats the writers reveal. These are nearly hopeless dilemmas to resolve in the real world – and I can’t help but note that the solutions offered by Sherlock are Christological in essence, i.e., a complete self-sacrifice for the deliverance of others. Bravo for the brilliant work all around!

  3. Sherlock leaves me in awe almost every time. This episode was absolutely magnificent. The best yet? Not after “The Reichenbach Fall”, which should go down as some of the best 90 minutes in television history, but with Sherlock it’s like saying “The Departed” is worse than “Goodfellas”.

    Magnussen was scene-stealing. I hated him. Absolutely hated him. He was a vile, repulsive, manipulative, bully of a man. And it came through so, so well. In many ways that face-flicking scene at the end with Watson is practically gruesome. It’s difficult to watch. Ultimately, you had to kill him. Like the original story already told us, there’s simply no other way to deal with scum like that. He was otherwise untouchable.

    And Martin Freeman needs to win a Bafta for his performance. His scene in Baker Street after Sherlock (rather brilliantly) manipulates Mary into tipping her hand to Watson (in a lovely nod and inversion of a similar scene in “The Empty House”) was nothing short of amazing. Nobody conveys emotion better with facial expressions than Martin Freeman. I was frustrated when Watson took her back (and didn’t even read her files!), but it made sense for the character and it was the right way for the story to go. The introduction of a baby into the mix is going to be interesting. It almost never helps shows when that sort of thing happens, but I have nothing but faith in Sherlock’s writing team.

    The “mind palace” scene that took place after Mary shot Sherlock was brilliantly filmed and acted – especially Andrew Scott’s cameo.

    And oh yeah – the ending. THE ENDING. OH MY GOSH. I started applauding. I was sitting on my bed at the time, with one other person in the room who wasn’t watching the show. The way they did it was so, so perfect.

    Sherlock is more than the best show on TV. It’s one of the greatest shows of all time.

  4. Wouldn’t that be something if Sherlock faked Moriarty coming back just so he wouldn’t be exiled and ultimately die in Eastern Europe… Then Moriarty would be a fake like Sherlock said before he jumped…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s